Mafia V: Day Three (May 9th-11th): A Single Reprieve

[Teapot]

Sorry for the long delay. Waiting on something that never came and watching Breaking Bad >> <<.

Joshawott has been defenestrated out of an extremely high window. He did not survive, and is a townie.

D: Joshey died, I can reveal he was a townie He's just text me back telling me so but I'm also sorta glad but that is due to the fact only one person died, it is unfortunate that Joshey did die because he seemed a very skilled player despite this being his first time, I actually had suspicions when talking with Shiny during the wait that he would actually win looks like I was wrong :x

Ooh, Breaking Bad~

Four villagers and two Mafia down- We need to step up our game, guys, or else things won't look good. I still find NidoRich suspicious, but after a bit of rereading the previous day's comments I also have some suspicions for Riley and Jada- But that leads me to think I am subconsciously picking out the newest members, for whatever reason.

I think the real problem is that the more experienced players are getting too good at this game. But for now, I'll sit out the rest of the comments of the day and see what others have to say. If there's nothing I can find myself agreeing with, I'll most likely be going for Richard.

I actually agree with you that some people are getting too good because not one of them aside Sem and to an extent Red are raising suspicion but know you have brought that up the more experienced seem to be taking a backseat role rather than be more vocal like they were in previous games, this worries me a little.

One of the major components of the Sem bandwagon has been killed to the point only 3 remain; Me, Tan and RMA. I think I might back off from Sem however because if Sem was Mafia I doubt he would make a slip-up like that. If I was to predict the outcome of the lynch vote, I would have a guess it's probably me or Rich who's going :|

Also I find it ironic that my title says Cry, Sem Cry as soon as I back off him

[Linkachu]

One of the major components of the Sem bandwagon has been killed to the point only 3 remain; Me, Tan and RMA. I think I might back off from Sem however because if Sem was Mafia I doubt he would make a slip-up like that. If I was to predict the outcome of the lynch vote, I would have a guess it's probably me or Rich who's going :|

Funny that. I currently find Jada's comments from the previous day a helluva lot more suspicious than NidoRich.

But you Riley... I'm a bit curious of your opening post:

D: Joshey died, I can reveal he was a townie He's just text me back telling me so

Why did you say "I can reveal that he was a townie" when Petey already revealed it? It sounds like you genuinely knew he was a townie in advance, but I can't imagine how unless you're the detective. It's even more curious because just the previous day you were highly suspicious of him... But maybe I'm just taking your post out of context, so I'll not jump to conclusions.

I'll need to look over the previous day to determine if anyone else stands out as being suspicious. It's rather interesting that only one Mafia family voted this 'round~

o_o I'm sure when I posted it didn't say "and is a townie". I honestly must have read it too fast or it magically appeared :|

How could you possibly know if only one family voted or if they both targeted Josh. I dunno where to carry on from this but it made alarm bells ring for some reason xD

Also I've just realised that the Mafia are still going for people who will or have previously been influential or good players ._.

And also why would I go for Josh if I was Mafia it is too obvious and Mafia are obviously setting me up and framing me so you guys can lynch me and they can take out more townies :|

Also I hate having to delete posts to edit them :|

[Linkachu]

How could you possibly know if only one family voted or if they both targeted Josh. I dunno where to carry on from this but it made alarm bells ring for some reason xD

Petey's comments pretty much gave it away.

And also why would I go for Josh if I was Mafia it is too obvious and Mafia are obviously setting me up and framing me so you guys can lynch me and they can take out more townies :|

I didn't accuse you of being Mafia tho, Riley. I said your comment was curious, and it certainly was. As far as I'm concerned you're just as likely to be Mafia as you're not to be, and we've already learned from previous games that people will lynch their buddies simply to make it look like a frame job when it actually isn't. It's a risky yet clever way to convince others of your innocence.

One way or another, it's pretty clear that Josh's death wasn't a random hit but it doesn't exactly help us guess at who may have lynched him either.

Also I hate having to delete posts to edit them :|

You shouldn't need to. Is the edit button not showing up for you on this board?

[Demelza]

o_o I'm sure when I posted it didn't say "and is a townie". I honestly must have read it too fast or it magically appeared :|

The post actually didn't say Josh was a townie when it was first posted, Peter likely edited it after Riley made his post.

For me I'm gonna wait and see what the others say before voicing my thoughts too much (In a game like this that gets you killed), for now I suspect Richard like the rest of you, but want to see what he has to say for himself.

We're losing townies fast though, whoever we lynch next needs to be mafia. =/

How could you possibly know if only one family voted or if they both targeted Josh. I dunno where to carry on from this but it made alarm bells ring for some reason xD

Also I've just realised that the Mafia are still going for people who will or have previously been influential or good players ._.

Because if the other Family did choose another person, he or she would be dead. Unless one of them abstained from killing, which I deem highly unlikely, they have to both have voted for Josh- Because that's the only reason he would be the only one killed off.

Also I guess that means I'm in the clear! /tauntingfate

You shouldn't need to. Is the edit button not showing up for you on this board?

Nope it isn't. And this is the 3rd weird thing to happen to me on charms today xD

... Actually, the edit button isn't showing for me either. Is this intentional or did the forum frak up again?

Well with the looks of things forums have fraked up again, chat has aswell which is the location of two of the oddities for me today

[Demelza]

On the subject of the edit button, its showing for me. =/

D: Lucky, I have to copy, delete, paste, write additional stuff ._. Very tedious

Objection!!! [/Wright'd]

I really have no reason for writing that other than simply feeling like it. :x

Anyways, I'm one for the line of thinking that one of the mafia families simply chose not to kill somebody. Based off the context clues of Petey's post that was what I gathered. I'm assuming that it was the remaining member of Shiny and Dway's family that did not kill, seeing as the other family is still wholly intact.

I'm still curious of Riley, and a bit suspicious of Rich (though I would really love for somebody to gather some real evidence to back this claim, as I haven't been doing that myself and I'd love to know why some people have been clamoring for his lynching all game. It seems to just be a tradition thing to suspect him now and not offer any reasons for it). I'm still most curious of Jada after her last remarks of Day 2. Very curious.

Edit: I have the edit powers! I am superior to you! >: D

HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM.

Poor Josh. So innocent.

Anyway, I am finding NidoRich slightly suspicious, although I would love to see what he says to back up his case of innocence.

My main suspicions land on Jada, though. She's clamouring for attention. You only do stuff like that in a game of Mafia if you want to be killed. So the jury is out. What do you have to say for yourself, Jada? And don't use the "I'm new to this, so I wouldn't have been given a special role" excuse, because I have explained to you two games in a row that experience does not matter. I have my suspicions squarely directed at you.

I've also noticed that the vocal people seem to be disappearing at a an alarming rate. With that in mind I think me and Red in particular are in trouble in that sense other than that all I have to say is you quieter ones will have to speak up eventually ^^

[Teapot]

Vocal people getting offed quickly is actually a demonstrable pattern. It makes late games very, very quiet

I'm assuming that it was the remaining member of Shiny and Dway's family that did not kill, seeing as the other family is still wholly intact.

I have proof you are Mafia >D Unless you are Mafia you don't know if one Mafia is still fully intact. You clearly state this and you are too influencing this game it for the best getting rid of you now. This is in even clearer day than Shiny and everyone can see it

Lynch Red

Shiny and Dway said they were in the same family, not only to me, but in the open. So yeah, two mafia gone and of the same family. That leaves one family fully intact.

You have no logic and that was a snap decision to lynch me. Now I'm forced to wonder why you wanted me dead? If I remember correctly you would not acknowledge that Shiny was Mafia, despite constantly admitting she was. I honestly want to know what all of you were thinking there. Shiny admits she's mafia and you all decide, "nope, not gonna vote for her. Gonna vote for Sem because he's somehow suspicious."

Also Riley, I've been influencing this game for our good. I killed Sho who was stirring things up poorly, and then I worked my ass off to get Shiny out of the game despite people trying their damndest to keep her in the game. So why do you want me out? I've done nothing but good things and yet you want me out. If that was your proof, Riley, you need to learn what "proof" is, my boy.